Showing posts with label Piet Hesselink. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Piet Hesselink. Show all posts

Tuesday, 26 April 2022

Tsutsumi Hozan Ryu Jujutsu ... or Not?


Rob Hymas was one of the senior jujutsu instructors for Jan de Jong from the late 1970s until JDJ's passing in 2003.  He was one of three that JDJ promoted to sixth dan shortly before he passed away. After JDJ passed, RH formed his own school, Indian Ocean Dojo. The 'welcome' page of the IOD website states: 'This school teaches the strategies, tactics, and techniques of Tsutsumi Hozan-ryu jujutsu.' Does it?

Before JDJ passed away, the Jan de Jong Self Defence School promoted that it taught Tsutsumi Hozan ryu jujutsu. Did it?

Jan de Jong Martial Arts Fitness is an offshoot (ryuha - see below) of the JDJSDS when JDJ passed. The principal of JDJMAF is JDJ's daughter, Maggie Connelly (nee de Jong) (1st dan) with the head instructor being Paul Connelly (6th dan) who was a contemporary of RH. Their senior instructor is Daryl Cook who the JDJMAF website states: 'Holds dan grades in Jan de Jong Ju Jutsu.' Does he? And how does JDJ jujutsu fit in with THR jujutsu?

DC is shodan. I have fond memories of doing part of my shodan with DC. One particularly memorable part was the Kentai Ichi no Kata, a Yoseikan kata, conducted in JDJ's backyard. Before we could commence the grading, the poo of JDJ's great dane, Sasha, had to be removed from the grading area. I suspect that not many martial arts gradings commence with the removal of dog poo. And dear God that dog could poo! I was uchi deashi with JDJ and it was my job to clean up Sasha's dog poo most mornings. A price you pay to be uchi deashi within the JDJ tradition it would appear.

The ude hiji nage defence that DC demonstrated on me, the uke, had me thrown into the pot plants at the front of the sliding doors into the JDJ residence. A challenge was not to be distracted when recovering from the throw, in a formal matter, with dirt and leaves falling off me. 

Hasso gamae ... resulted in me stabbing a lemon above me hanging from the lemon tree that I was standing under at this end of the grading arena. I had to surreptitiously try to remove the tip of my sword from the hanging lemon before attacking DC. And then trying to concentrate when a fly was crawling up my nose was a challenge that I suspect few have had to contend with when performing this kata, ... although, is it something Japanese swordsman had to contend with back in the day?

DC was #15 on the list of shodans awarded by JDJ, one after me, and without taking into account the shodan JDJ awarded in Holland during WWII. DC and I were awarded shodan in ... Tsutsumi jujutsu. JDJ never, to the best of my knowledge, awarded a grading of any rank in Tsutsumi Hozan ryu jujutsu. 'What's going on here?' as Gary Klein would say in respect to gaining insight.

Tsutsumi Hozan ryu and Tsutsumi ryu are two different traditions according to James Shortt and Serge Mol, the latter being the more authoritative book. 'What's going on here?'

JDJMAF appears to be walking the association with THR back when they state, 'The style of Ju Jutsu taught at Jan de Jong Martial Arts Fitness is based on Tsutsumi Hozan Ryu Ju Jutsu whose origins can be traced back to 14th century Japan' (emphasis added). What does 'based' mean? What style of jujutsu are JDJMAF teaching? With that they are not explicit, although their reference to DC's qualifications would suggest JDJ jujutsu.

Where did 'JDJ jujutsu' come from? It started with Greg Palmer, another contemporary of RH and PC and who was awarded 4th dan by JDJ shortly before he passed away. GP always explained that JDJ referred to his teachings as THR jujutsu out of respect for his instructors, the Saitos, even though he'd considerably changed what he had been taught. 

I have argued throughout this blog that JDJ developed the entire jujutsu grading system and it would be a difficult exercise to identify what is uniquely THR within that grading system. I was discussing a change of name for what he was teaching with JDJ shortly before he passed away given the considerably changes that he had made to what he was taught. JDJ obviously took that approach when awarding RH, PC, and Peter Clarke 6th dan and GP 4th dan in JDJ jujutsu shortly before he passed away. It would appear that only JDJMAF have adopted that ryu name when grading jujutsu students, although I cannot be sure.

The assertion that the JDJ tradition is teaching THR jujutsu has been 'questioned' in the past, most visibly now in various internet forums. Fraud! they say. That's fair enough. So how do we respond to that accusation. Here I refer to Karl Friday in Legacies of the Sword:

Martial arts ryuha ... have historically tended to practice total transmission, in which all students certified as having mastered the school's kabala are given 'possession' of it. ... such students normally left their masters to open their own schools, teaching on their own authority; masters retained no residual control over former students or students of students. Each new graduate was free to modify their master's teachings as he saw fit, adding personal insights and/or techniques and ideas gleaned from other teachers. It was common practice for such graduates to change even the names of their styles, in effect, founding new ryuha and independent branches of ryuha in each generation. (1997, 18)

Dr. Friday defines the term ryuha as "branch of the current," representing the onward flow of a stream of thought; the branches betoken the splitting off that occurs as insights are passed from master to students, generation after generation.

To be sure, since time immemorial people have attempted to gained credibility by associating themselves with authoritative sources. There are many in the martial arts who attempt to gain credibility for what they are teaching by associating themselves with JDJ even though they only did a few lessons with him. I could do the same with the well-known and world-wide respected Wally Jay because I attended a seminar of his while I was living in London (but I don't).

The point is that you don't take a ryu/ryuha name at face value. You don't disparage the use of it on the same basis. JDJ's instructors may have very well studied THR jujutsu. They may very well have taught what they were taught to JDJ. On the other hand, they may have modified their master's teachings. JDJ most definitely did modify his masters' teachings. I seriously doubt that they would recognise what JDJ came to teach ... but does that make it more or less THR jujutsu? RH decided not to adopt the change in name of style that JDJ graded him 6th dan in. Peter Clark changed the name to Tsutsumi Jugo ryu jujutsu to reflect the origins of his style and the unique contribution that he has made. PC, in association with MC (nee de Jong), may or may not refer to their teachings as JDJ jujutsu. The point is that you look behind the name, as Friday's explanation clearly illustrates. In doing that, you maygain insights, having asked 'What's going on here?' and attempting to find answers to that question.




Thursday, 19 December 2019

'Let's don't think that we can learn this in 20 days'

My plans to terminate this blog are not going according to plan.

This blog accumulating the information and telling the story of Jan de Jong has and is attracting contributions from those who knew him and/or trained under him. The latest is a membership card from JDJ's school in Rotterdam in 1946.



Would love a current photo, and even a 1940s photo, of Leede 60, Rotterdam Zuid.

 The left hand side says: Please bring this card with you every first lesson of the month.

The right hand side says: The development of jiu jitsu has taken 20 decades. So lets don’t think that we can learn this in 20 days.

The card is dated 1946 and is number 69. 

The card is for Kees (Cees) Kranendonk. The Nationale Veteranen Commissie Budo in Holland published a eulogy for Kees on their Facebook page as he passed away this month. It would appear that he was still active in judo in Holland. Nearly 75 years in jujutsu and judo starting with JDJ right after WWII ended. JDJ would be chuffed.

 This photo is apparently a young Piet Hesselink who JDJ handed his school over to when he left Holland for Indonesia. Hesselink was reputedly the first shodan that JDJ graded.

This photo is reproduced for atmospherics about the time period we are discussing. It is of JDJ and Rienier Hulsk who he trained with when he arrived in Holland in 1940 before teaching for him and ultimately branching out with his own school.

One of the photos in the set with JDJ and RH has been reproduced in Naverteld verleden: Jiujitsu in het verzet in Nederland 1940-1945 (Retold past: Jiujitsu in the 1940-1945 resistance) by J.H.G. Smits. Most of the information in that book about JDJ was taken from this blog.

Friday, 5 August 2011

Jan de Jong Pt 3 - The War Years

In the last blog we'd left Jan de Jong travelling by boat to Holland in later 1939 to pursue a career as a pilot. He arrived in Holland in February 1940.

At the outbreak of WWII in 1939, the Netherlands declared itself neutral as it had been during WWI. This was not to be as Germany invaded on the morning of 10 May 1940. Hitler had hoped to conquer the country in just one day but his forces met unexpectedly fierce resistance. The German command received the following order on 13 May: 'Resistance in Rotterdam should be broken with all means, if necessary threaten with and carry out the annihilation (Vernichtung) of the city.' The Dutch and Germans were negotiating the surrender of the city when, just after midday on 14 May 1940, the heart of the city was almost completely destroyed by the Luftwaffe (a sentiment which is captured in Ossip Zadkine's statue Stad zonder hart ,'city without a heart').

The Germans employed shrecklichkeit. Shrecklichkeit ('frightfulness') is a term Hitler used to refer to the deliberate targeting of civilian populations to destroy civilian morale. The German's experimented with shrecklichkeit during the Spanish Civil War with the bombing of Guernica, then used it in Warsaw, Poland in 1939. In the early afternoon of 14 May 1940 it was Rotterdam's turn to experience shrecklichkeit. One third of the city was destroyed. Nearly 1,000 people were killed and over 80,000 lost their homes and more than 25,000 houses and buildings were destroyed. The fires raged on after the bombardment for weeks and the entire country sent fire brigades to Rotterdam. The bombing of Rotterdam would later become one of the war crimes Hermann Goering was indicted for.

De Jong sat on the roof of his apartment block watching the bombing of Rotterdam. On one of our European teaching tours, De Jong took myself and his daughter (Maggie) to see where he lived in Rotterdam during WWII. The photograph to the right is of the building with De Jong and his daughter standing in front of the front door. If it isn't the world's thinnest building it has to be up there. Looking up at the roof of that building as De Jong reminisced about the day he saw the heart of Rotterdam nearly completely destroyed was very evocative.

De Jong said that the Gestapo occupied a building on the same block but behind his apartment building. He used to listen to the BBC which was banned by the Nazi authorities and he hid the radio aerial down a gutter. They had to be constantly on the lookout when listening to the radio as the German's used mobile detector vehicles to locate radios and their listeners.

De Jong initially relied on the financial support of his father which dried up when the Nazis occupied Holland. He then survived on the borrowings from friends and was relieved when Reinier Hulsker offered him a position to teach jujutsu at his sports school. The entrepreneurial Hulsker taught jujutsu, that’s how they met, and he could see the opportunities for martial arts/self defence training in the forthcoming years. De Jong would forever refer to the day he started teaching jujutsu professionally as the day he retired. He was the living embodiment of Confucius’ saying: 'if you enjoy what you do, you’ll never work another day in your life.'

Within a year, De Jong had decided to open up his own school. Out of respect and friendship for his benefactor, he opened up his school on the opposite side of the city in order to not compete with Hulsker, even though this exposed him to greater personal dangers. Travel within the cities of Holland was a dangerous business. The Germans, with increasing frequency, would round-up all able-bodied men for forced labour in Germany. There was a time that De Jong was ordered to present himself for selection for these labour details which he avoided by forging papers saying he was studying at the local university which excluded him from selection.

There was also the risk of being randomly selected for execution in reprisal for Dutch Resistance activities. De Jong would recall the time when he and his friends were walking down the street and one of their number was selected among them to be executed. He's shown me a newspaper clipping which he's kept from those times which lists one of his friends as being among the executed.

In spite of these risks, De Jong opened and operated his first martial art school which proved to be successful, teaching approximately 300 students at its height. This is some feat today, let alone in Nazi occupied Holland. Kees van Deijk, a student of De Jong’s at that time, recalls that De Jong gave lessons in an 'ordinary private house' and that 'on the floor in this room was a kind of tarpaulin and under that straw which had to be filled up frequently. Sometimes there were complaints from the neighbours owing to the booming by us and all the other pupils. Jan invited them to come and see what we did. Complaints stopped.' Over fifty years later, Van Deijk’s impression of these lessons was that 'the lessons that Jan gave were great, we worked hard with of course a lot of fun. That was Jan too!'

When De Jong left Holland after the war, he turned the school over to Piet Hesselink. They didn’t maintained contact, however, in 1994, whilst teaching in Holland, De Jong was approached by the tearful grandfather of a young student who was attending the seminar. It was Hesselink … and he was still teaching. When approached by Hesselink, De Jong, with his amazing memory, thought for a moment and then said: 'You’re Piet Hesselink.' Hesselink confirmed De Jong’s identification after 50 years and produced his membership card from De Jong’s school during WWII. De Jong graded Hesselink shodan (black belt) during the war years. Shodan in what is another matter. It might have been in whatever Hulsker was teaching. Hesselink's story is one which would add further information to that of De Jong's.

In addition to training with Hulsker, Jan de Jong sought out other jujutsu practitioners. He trained with, among others, Mark van Gich and Maurice van Nieuwenhuizen, but he was most impressed with Jan Boretius whose jujutsu he described as being 'very dynamic and effective.' Given his predilection for dynamism and effectiveness in latter years, this is high praise indeed. Boretius lived in Amsterdam, so the extended travel exposed De Jong to greater dangers. He would recall, and which has been misquoted in various interviews, a time he was forced to utilise his skills to extract himself from a predicament he encountered when a German soldier asked him for an Auswiez (permit to stay in Holland).

Nieuwenhuizen went on to become an important figure in Dutch martial arts after the war. He wrote a few books on judo/jujutsu and was the inspiration for the cartoon and film hero 'Dick Bos'. Nieuwenhuizen was also one of the founding members of the Netherlands Judo Federation and one of his students was the Olympic champion Anto Geeslink.

De Jong was recruited into the so-called Dutch Resistance early on during the Nazi occupation. 'So-called' because the Dutch Resistance had no central command or control. Individuals recruited relatives, friends and neighbours to join groups who often had no outside links at all and who conducted their operations as they saw fit. Association with these groups was risk laden as capture often resulted in torture then execution or deportation to a concentration camp. These risks were exacerbated by the geography of the countryside. The lack of mountain and forested terrain did not provide hiding areas for large groups of marquis and the flat terrain and many bodies of water confined movement to established railroads, road networks and bridges, which were easily occupied by the Germans who established check points to prevent complete freedom of movement by the Dutch inhabitants. Then there was the risk of being informed upon. Due to the geographic proximity and the cultural ties with Germany, there were many Dutch who were sympathetic to the idea of German nationalism.

In addition to all these risks, there was Englandspiel – 'the English game' as the Germans called their penetration of the Dutch Resistance. The Allies Special Operations Executive (SOE) operations in Holland had been penetrated in March 1942 and they were convinced, through SOE’s 'sole agent' (the Germans), that a vigorous underground movement was being built when in reality the entire operation was compromised. Abwehr Lieutenant Colonel Giskes, the officer in charge of the operation, showed a certain panache when, after the operation had been blown, he signed off to London on 1 April 1944, appropriately April Fools Day, with:
Messrs Blunt, Bingham and Successors Ltd. London. … you are trying to make business in the Netherlands without our assistance. We think this rather unfair in view of our long and successful co-operation as your sole agents. But never mind, when you come to pay a visit to the Continent you may be assured that you will be received with the same care and result as all those who you sent us before. So long!
De Jong very rarely spoke of his operational experience during the war. Of the experiences he confided in me, there is no doubt he was engaged in active service for most of the occupation of Holland. When we were walking in Amsterdam one day, he pointed out a large church (or cathedral, I don't know the difference). He stood there for a moment and told me of a fire-fight between the Germans and Dutch resistance on the roof of the building. He went to their aid by climbing up into the ceiling and taking some tiles down to get onto the roof, only to find one of his comrades had been shot in the head and killed. He also spoke of hijacking a meat wagon only to find a German officer was hiding in the back. They had to kill the officer, having no means of imprisoning him, to which the German's responded with their standard reprisal - executions. When questioned on his operational experience, De Jong would usually reply:
[this is] not a time I really like to talk about. Because war is such a stupid thing and it turns people into creatures that do the most horrible things to other human beings.
The ending of the war had just as profound an effect on De Jong as the war itself. The German’s had plundered Holland during the occupation. There was no coal, no electricity, no wood; there was no running water, no sewers and no waste disposal. Food had always been scarce, but by the time the Germans left it had become a rare commodity. The population were starving and were forced to eat tulip bulbs, and on occasion, family pets. They would put an old shoe in boiling water in an attempt to infuse some sort of taste of meat from the leather into the 'soup'. Then nature imposed a harsher winter than was the norm. More than 20,000 people died due to the deprivations of what came to be known as the 'Hunger Winter'. De Jong would recall how he had to survive on one loaf of stale bread for an entire week and how bitterly cold it was. For the rest of his life he would attend to his meals with a single-mindedness that could not be easily dissuaded and he was unable to leave a morsel of food on his plate. He would leave Holland not to return for another twenty years, and never during winter.

His eating habits became a bit of a 'thing' between us. On occasion I would attempt to engage him in conversation while he was eating, no mean feat I can tell you. On all subjects he had no problem ignoring any attempts at conversation; all conversations bar one - jujutsu. I'd deliberately raise some issue of interest related to jujutsu with De Jong while he was trying to eat and you could almost see the internal battle being waged. He knew what I was doing but still he had to fight (and often lost) the impulse to talk about jujutsu. On one of the last visits I paid to De Jong before he passed away, he proudly informed me that he had left some food on his plate. It was a moment of connection between us which appears to all intents and purposes to be trivial, but it wasn't as we both knew what it meant.

De Jong got married during the war and fathered two children. He also studied physiotherapy during the war years. After the war, a friend of his father offered him a civilian position as a physiotherapist attached to the Royal Netherlands Indies Army (KNIL). The promise of a posting to the warmer more plentiful Dutch East Indies, later to be known as Indonesia, secured his commitment. That and the watch he was offered.

Unfortunately I was unable to secure a Resistance medal for De Jong before he passed away. I applied to the Netherland authorities a little too late when they were awarding these medals.